Red Herring
A sharp, sneaky category puzzle that looks its age and plays far better than it looks.
Our review
Long before word-grouping puzzles became a daily habit for half the internet, Blue Ox Family Games had one on phones. Red Herring arrived in 2014 with a mean little twist: some of the words on the board belong nowhere and exist only to lead you astray. The puzzle design is first-rate. The packaging is, let us say, vintage.
How it plays
You are shown a board of words and told they fall into categories. Your job is to sort them. The complication is in the name: mixed in with the real members are red herrings, words chosen because they look as if they belong somewhere and do not. The decoys are picked with care, usually because they could plausibly join one of the real groups. Only one arrangement is correct, and nothing is timed, so this is a game for thinking, not tapping. Three difficulty levels let a family share it, and the top one is stiff enough for a seasoned solver. A puzzle takes anywhere from two minutes to a quarter of an hour, depending on how stubborn you are.
Presentation
Here is where marks come off. Red Herring plays in landscape, an oddity among phone word games, so you turn the phone sideways and use two hands. The style is plain and looks like what it is, a design from 2014: word tiles, flat colors, little animation. In its favor, it is quick, legible and free of clutter, and at 85 MB it is a fraction of the size of its glossier rivals. Function over fashion. I can live with that, though a portrait mode would be welcome.
Ads and purchases
Blue Ox Family Games gives you 25 puzzles and a daily puzzle for free. The listing declares advertising, so ads run in the free game, and I see no ad-removal item among the listed purchases. More puzzles are sold in named packs, the way a newsstand sells puzzle books: 50-puzzle packs such as Curiosity, Allegro, Spelunking and Serendipity at $1.99 each, Quantum Leap with 175 puzzles at $4.99, and an archive of older daily puzzles from July to December 2014 at $3.99. Unlimited Hints is a flat $2.99. No coins or mystery boxes appear on the list. You pay for puzzles and you get puzzles.
- Decoy words make every grouping a trap
- No timer and one clean solution
- Honest puzzle-pack pricing with no coins
- Landscape-only layout on a phone
- Only 25 free puzzles before packs
Verdict
Lateral thinkers who enjoy sorting words into groups, and being fooled now and then, should download this on iOS or Android and work through the free 25 before deciding on a pack. It is a thinker's game and a good one. Pass if you need modern polish, portrait play or a bottomless free supply, because Red Herring gives you a sample and then, quite reasonably, asks to be paid.
If the red herrings are winning, today's Red Herring categories and solutions are posted daily.
Similar games
All reviewsPuzzle Page
Work through a daily page of mixed puzzles, from crosswords and sudoku to nonograms and codewords.
Read reviewHeads Up!
Hold the phone to your forehead and guess the word on screen from your friends' clues.
Read reviewEveryday Puzzles
Solve a daily set of mini-games, from crosswords and cryptograms to word ladders and sudoku.
Read review